You hit 40 and suddenly everyone’s got supplement advice.
Your doctor mentions vitamin D. Your buddy at the gym swears by testosterone boosters. Some wellness influencer wants you spending $200 monthly on their “longevity stack.”
Most of it is expensive garbage designed to empty your wallet.
Here’s the reality: your body does change after 40. Your gut absorbs fewer nutrients. Your cellular membranes start breaking down. Your testosterone drops about 1% per year. But you don’t need a pharmacy’s worth of pills to handle it.
Having a Human Biology degree, I spend a lot of time reading up on health and science topics, but I’m not a doctor, so don’t take any of this as “medical advice.” What I can do is show you what the research actually says works.
Let me break down the seven supplements that science backs for men over 40, and the three popular ones you can completely ignore.
Talk to your doctor before trying new supplements to see if they’re right for you. Some can negatively interact with certain prescription medications or worsen symptoms of underlying health conditions.
1. Phosphatidylcholine (PC) for Brain and Liver Function
This is the supplement most guys have never heard of, but it might be the most important one on this list.
Phosphatidylcholine makes up 30-40% of your cell membranes, especially in your brain and liver. After 40, your PC levels naturally decline. That’s when the brain fog hits. The fatigue kicks in. Your metabolism slows down.
Research from MIT shows that PC supplementation improves memory formation and recall. Another study found it significantly reduces fatigue and supports liver function.
Your liver processes everything you eat, drink, and every toxin you’re exposed to. When it’s sluggish, everything else suffers.
The problem? Most PC supplements are poorly formulated. Your body can’t absorb them properly. You need a liposomal form that actually gets into your cells.
BodyBio PC is properly balanced and actually works. Customers consistently report clearer thinking within days of starting it.
Who should take it: Most men over 40 can benefit from 2-4 softgels daily with food.
2. Omega-3 Fatty Acids for Heart and Brain Health
Omega-3s are one of the most researched supplements in existence.
These fatty acids reduce chronic inflammation throughout your body, support heart health, and protect your brain. Research shows they slow cognitive decline and reduce the risk of Alzheimer’s disease.
A study published in Atherosclerosis found that omega-3 supplementation significantly reduced heart disease risk markers. Another in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition showed improved memory and cognitive function in older adults.
Exploratory studies have even found that omega-3, combined with vitamin D and exercise, may help slow biological aging.
The best source is fatty fish like salmon, sardines, and mackerel. If you’re eating those 2-3 times per week, you’re probably fine. If not, supplement with fish oil providing at least 1,000mg of combined EPA and DHA daily.
Who should take it: Most people over 40 can take 1-2 grams of omega-3 fish oil capsules per day. Just avoid high doses if you’re taking blood thinners.
3. Vitamin D3 + K2 for Bones and Testosterone
If you work indoors, you’re probably deficient in vitamin D.
Research shows that over 40% of American adults have insufficient vitamin D levels. Low vitamin D is linked to low testosterone, weak bones, poor immune function, and higher risk of falls.
Vitamin D3 and K2 work together in a specific way. D3 is necessary for calcium absorption for bone and muscle strength. K2 helps prevent the buildup of minerals in your arteries and makes proteins involved in blood clotting and bone metabolism.
A study in Hormone and Metabolic Research found that men who supplemented with vitamin D saw significant increases in testosterone levels. They’re critical for immune balance, bone health, and vascular strength.
Your body makes vitamin D from sunlight, but unless you’re spending 30 minutes outside daily with skin exposed, you’re not getting enough. After 40, your skin becomes less efficient at producing it anyway.
Who should take it: Supplements containing both vitamins D3 and K2 are specifically helpful for people over 50. Take 2,000-4,000 IU daily with a meal containing fat. Use caution if you’re taking Warfarin or have existing calcium disorders or kidney dysfunction.
4. B Vitamins for Energy and Cognitive Health
B vitamins are criminally underrated for men over 40.
There are eight types of B vitamins, and each one plays a crucial role in your health. They help with metabolism, DNA production, and immune system function, and can protect neural pathways and enhance energy.
As you age, your stomach acid decreases, which means you absorb less B12 from food. Studies show that B vitamin deficiency is linked to cognitive decline, fatigue, and even depression in older adults.
Researchers have suggested that vitamin B12, in particular, may be involved in aging at the cellular level. B vitamins like B6, B12, and B9 (folate) have been shown to help with cognition before diagnosis of mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease.
Most drugstore brands use cheap, synthetic forms your body barely absorbs. You need a high-potency B-complex that includes all eight B vitamins in their active, methylated forms.
BodyBio B-Vitamins Hi-Potency delivers methylated B vitamins that your body can actually use. No fillers, no junk.
Who should take it: If bloodwork shows you have low vitamin B levels, take one capsule daily with breakfast. B12 is particularly recommended for vegans since it’s primarily found in animal products.
5. Magnesium for Sleep, Muscle, and Heart Health
Magnesium is involved in over 300 biochemical reactions in your body.
It regulates muscle and nerve function, blood sugar levels, blood pressure, and sleep quality. Yet 48% of Americans don’t get enough magnesium from their diet.
For men over 40, magnesium becomes even more critical. Research shows it helps maintain muscle mass, supports heart health, and significantly improves sleep quality. A study in the Journal of Research in Medical Sciences found that magnesium supplementation improved insomnia in older adults.
Low levels of magnesium are also linked to increased chronic inflammation and other concerning cellular changes, which may raise your risk of conditions like heart disease, cancer, and Alzheimer’s disease.
Most magnesium supplements cause digestive issues. You want magnesium glycinate for general use or magnesium citrate if you need help with regularity.
Who should take it: Magnesium typically helps most adults, especially those with a deficiency diagnosed through blood work. Take 300-400mg before bed. Men over 70 should try to get 400-420mg per day.
6. Creatine for Muscle Mass and Brain Function
Creatine isn’t just for 20-year-old gym bros anymore.
It’s one of the most researched supplements in existence, with over 500 studies showing its benefits. And those benefits extend way beyond building muscle.
According to experts, creatine helps preserve muscle mass and reduce the risk of muscle wasting (sarcopenia) as you get older. It also helps with inflammation and joint health.
But here’s what nobody talks about: creatine improves brain function. Some evidence suggests that creatine supplementation for older adults can enhance memory, though more research is needed.
Your brain uses massive amounts of energy, and creatine helps provide it. Studies show it improves memory, reduces mental fatigue, and may even protect against neurological diseases.
Who should take it: Most creatine comes in powder form that’s mixed into beverages. Take 5 grams daily, any time of day. No need for loading phases. The supplement is great for active people, but use it with caution if you have existing kidney issues.
7. Fiber for Gut Health and Disease Prevention
This isn’t technically a supplement, but fiber deserves a spot here because most men over 40 aren’t getting nearly enough.
You need 30 grams daily. Most guys get about 15.
According to experts, fiber supports your gut barrier’s integrity and calms chronic inflammation. It’s been associated with a lower risk of all-cause mortality, as well as a lower risk of death from cardiovascular disease or cancer.
Research from Harvard shows that men who consume adequate fiber have a 40% lower risk of heart disease and stroke. Another study found high fiber intake is associated with longer lifespan and reduced risk of chronic disease.
Fiber does a lot more than keep you regular. It feeds the beneficial bacteria in your gut, helps regulate blood sugar, lowers cholesterol, and keeps you feeling full, which prevents weight gain.
The best sources are whole foods. I wrote an entire article about how to melt fat with high-fiber foods that breaks down exactly what to eat.
Who should take it: The vast majority of Americans don’t get enough fiber each day. If you struggle to hit your goals, daily fiber supplements containing apple fiber could help improve your gut and immune health as you age. Start slowly to avoid digestive discomfort.
The 3 Supplements You Should Skip
Not everything pushed by the supplement industry is worth your money.
Skip This: Generic Multivitamins
Most multivitamins contain poorly absorbed forms of nutrients in doses too low to matter. They’re formulated to be cheap, not effective.
The research on multivitamins is mixed at best. A major study published in JAMA found that multivitamins didn’t reduce risk of heart disease, cancer, or cognitive decline in older adults.
If you’re taking the individual supplements I listed above, you don’t need a multi. Save your money.
Skip This: Testosterone Boosters
The supplement aisle is full of products claiming to boost testosterone naturally. Most of them are complete garbage.
Studies on popular ingredients like tribulus terrestris, fenugreek, and D-aspartic acid show minimal to no effect on testosterone levels in healthy men. The ones that do work are either dangerous or illegal.
If you genuinely have low testosterone, you need to see a doctor and get actual treatment. If you’re just trying to maintain healthy levels, focus on sleep, strength training, and avoiding excess body fat.
Skip This: High-Dose Antioxidant Supplements
Vitamin C, vitamin E, beta-carotene in mega-doses sound great in theory. In practice, they might do more harm than good.
A study called the SELECT trial found that high-dose vitamin E actually increased prostate cancer risk. Other research suggests that flooding your body with antioxidants can interfere with beneficial stress responses from exercise.
Get your antioxidants from colorful vegetables and berries, not pills.
How to Actually Take Supplements (The Part Nobody Explains)
Buying supplements is easy. Taking them consistently is where most guys fail.
Here’s my system: keep your daily supplements in the kitchen, not hidden in a bathroom cabinet. Take them with breakfast every morning. Set a phone reminder if you need to.
Quality matters more than you think. Look for third-party testing from organizations like NSF or USP to ensure you’re actually getting what the label claims. The FDA doesn’t regulate supplements the same way it does foods and medications, which means there’s a lot of junk out there.
Start with one or two supplements first. See how your body responds over 2-3 weeks before adding more. This way, you’ll actually know what’s working.
And remember: supplements are exactly what the name says. They supplement a foundation of good nutrition, regular exercise, quality sleep, and stress management. No pill will fix a fundamentally broken lifestyle.
But when you’ve got the basics dialed in? The right supplements can be the difference between just surviving your 40s and actually thriving.
Other Tips for Healthy Aging
Supplements alone cannot replace a healthy lifestyle. To live longer and healthier, it’s crucial to:
- Eat nutritious food
- Exercise regularly
- Manage stress
- Connect with others
- Attend regular checkups with your doctor
Supplements are meant to amplify, not replace, other activities. I really view supplements as the cherry on top, assuming you’re doing all of those other lifestyle changes.
The Bottom Line
You don’t need fifteen different supplements cluttering your counter.
You need seven: phosphatidylcholine for brain and cellular health, omega-3s for heart and brain health, vitamin D3 + K2 for bones and testosterone, B vitamins for energy and cognition, magnesium for sleep and muscle, creatine for muscle and brain function, and fiber for gut health.
Skip the generic multivitamins, testosterone boosters, and high-dose antioxidants. They’re expensive and don’t work.
Focus on quality over quantity. Taking supplements cannot guarantee you’ll live longer, but certain ones could lower your risk of disease and tamp down inflammation, which may protect your health as you age.
Your 40s don’t have to mean declining health and energy. With the right supplements supporting a solid foundation of diet and exercise, you can feel better at 45 than you did at 35.
Want more straight talk about health for men over 40? Sign up for my Freedom Over 40 newsletter for weekly tips that actually work.
